Are director’s loan accounts dangerous? Not in themselves. But an overdrawn director’s loan account that keeps growing, with no plan to clear it, can turn into a personal tax bill you never saw coming. A recent tribunal case is a costly reminder that settling a director’s loan does not necessarily settle the tax.
What is a director’s loan account (DLA)?
If you own a limited company, you might think you can take money out whenever you need it — to cover the mortgage, household bills and family life.
But the company’s money isn’t automatically your money, even if you own every share.
Think of your company as a separate person, a bit like your best friend or flatmate. Having access to their bank account doesn’t mean you can help yourself. You need an agreement about what the money is for and whether you’ll pay it back.
With a company, that arrangement needs to be properly recorded. Are you taking a salary, a valid dividend, repayment of money you previously lent the business, or reimbursement of business expenses?
If it’s none of those, you may be borrowing from the company. That borrowing is recorded in your director’s loan account (DLA). If you take out more than the company owes you, your DLA becomes overdrawn — meaning you owe the company money.
Perhaps you intend to repay it. Perhaps you expect the next set of accounts to show enough profit for a dividend.
But an expectation of future profits doesn’t turn today’s withdrawal into a dividend. Until it is properly repaid or cleared, that debt remains yours.
From a financial management point of view, that balance deserves the same attention as an overdue customer account. The cash has left the business, and you need a credible plan for getting it back or clearing the debt properly.
The case: more than £352,000 in tax and penalties
In Fullerton v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1479 (TC), decided on 26 October 2026, the tribunal upheld an income tax assessment of £282,685.99 and a careless-inaccuracy penalty of £69,964.78.
The director’s company had entered liquidation. The tribunal accepted a loan balance of £838,609. A settlement payment of £96,650.64 left £741,958.36 released or written off.
That write-off was missing from her 2018/19 tax return. She believed the settlement dealt with all related liabilities.
The tribunal disagreed: settling the company’s repayment claim did not settle her personal income tax. Her appeal was dismissed.
Writing off a director’s loan can create personal tax
For an owner-director within the close-company loan rules, releasing or writing off the loan can trigger personal income tax under section 415 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005. The amount is generally taxed as dividend income.
That is separate from the company’s section 455 tax, the temporary charge (currently 35.75% of the loan) that applies when a loan is still outstanding nine months after the company’s year end. Paying the company’s loan-related tax does not make the director’s borrowing disappear, or settle the personal tax on a later write-off. The company may qualify for section 455 relief when the loan is repaid, released or written off.
A partial payment accepted in full and final settlement can release the remaining balance and trigger the personal charge. You do not have to receive fresh cash at that point: the tax can arise because an existing debt has been forgiven.
This is why any proposed settlement needs to be assessed for both its repayment cost and its tax cost. National Insurance consequences may also need checking.
“I thought it was all dealt with” needs evidence
The tribunal accepted that reasonable reliance on competent professional advice can protect against a carelessness finding. But here there was no convincing evidence of specific advice about the personal tax consequences, or of the checks made before approving the return.
My practical recommendation is simple: ask the question directly and keep the answer.
“What does this agreement mean for my personal tax return, and how much tax will I need to pay?”
Give your Accountant or personal tax adviser the loan reconciliation and settlement documents. Agree who will calculate the liability and report it.
Five steps to keep your director’s loan account under control
- Know your balance every month. Include it in your management accounts. Understand what created it and whether it is increasing.
- Plan personal withdrawals alongside business cash flow. Decide what the business can afford after allowing for wages, suppliers, tax and working capital.
- Check profits before relying on dividends. A dividend needs sufficient available profits and proper paperwork. Expected future profits are not a sound basis for promising that today’s borrowing will be cleared.
- Agree a realistic repayment plan. Put amounts and dates against it. Ask your Accountant to check the tax consequences of the proposed method.
- Take advice before a write-off, settlement or liquidation. Understand the personal tax cost before committing, and make sure the relevant information reaches whoever prepares your return.
For more on paying yourself tax-efficiently through salary and dividends, read our guide Tax Planning for Business Owners.
The key takeaways
- An overdrawn director’s loan account is a real debt. You owe your company the money, even if you own every share.
- Settling with the company is not settling with HMRC. Any part of the loan that is released or written off can be taxed on you personally as dividend income.
- The company’s section 455 tax is a separate charge. Paying it does not clear your debt or your personal tax.
- Get advice in writing. If you rely on advice, keep a record of it. Without evidence, a careless-inaccuracy penalty is likely.
- Watch the balance monthly. If it keeps growing, review what you are drawing, what the company is earning and what it can afford.
Your director’s loan account belongs in your monthly financial conversation. At Blueski Financial Synergy, we help business owners understand these numbers and plan ahead. If you owe your company money and are unsure how to clear it, let’s talk.
Find out before it costs you. Book a free 30-minute call with Josef. We’ll look at your latest figures and tell you what they’re not telling you. No charge, no obligation.
Book a meeting · T: 01664 774041 · M: 07887 921705 · E: Sales@MrBlueski.co.uk
Sources checked on 10 November 2026. The case concerns 2018/19, so its tax figures are not an illustration of current tax rates. This article is general information, not tax advice.